An Observation on Vintage Handplanes


Observe: I began penning this weblog entry greater than a 12 months
in the past. I shelved it and have revisited it a number of instances since.
Every time, I believed: I don’t want this type of grief. For
no matter cause (4 beers, maybe?), I supply this as an
commentary based mostly on instructing college students, each novice and

For the final decade I’ve had the privilege of instructing
woodworking college students everywhere in the world about hand instruments. I’m
not the very best trainer, however I’m listener and observer.

Firstly of each class, I make a suggestion to the
college students: “You might be welcome to make use of my instruments. You don’t need to
ask. Simply take them and return them when you find yourself carried out.”

I personal a mixture of classic and new planes – largely outdated Stanleys,
Lie-Nielsens and Veritas. I maintain them sharp, however they don’t
have any particular modifications. They’re simply planes proper off
the shelf which have been sharpened.

In nearly each class, there’s a scholar (or a number of college students)
who personal classic handplanes that they’ve restored and souped
up with aftermarket irons, chipbreakers and typically knobs and
totes. A sure share of those planes have been floor
floor and look higher than new.

I’m all the time keen to take a look at their planes as a result of I began out
by restoring outdated planes nicely earlier than there have been good fashionable
bench planes out there. I really like the outdated instruments and the way in which the
tote feels in my proper hand. I just like the patina that comes from
exhausting work and care. So I wish to take their classic planes for
a take a look at drive – planing in opposition to the grain of no matter nasty
stuff is mendacity round.

Now, the mantra that nearly each trainer repeats (together with
me) goes one thing like this: It doesn’t matter if in case you have
classic planes or new planes. Each might be tuned to a excessive
stage. Classic planes require time. New planes require cash.

It seems like an affordable assertion, however I don’t know if I
consider these phrases anymore.

And that’s as a result of I’m observer.


Throughout my lessons I watch my college students intently. It’s all about
decoding their physique language. Are they pissed off? Are they
about to throw a device to the ground? (This actually occurs.)

What I’ve noticed is that this: The scholars with the super-tuned
classic handplanes nearly all the time have a tendency to make use of – again and again –
my Lie-Nielsen and Veritas planes in the course of the class. They’ll
look forward to me to sharpen them after which decide them out of my device
chest. They put their classic planes under their bench or again
into their device bag. I’ve even seen a few of them order a
Veritas or Lie-Nielsen airplane on a cellphone throughout a category
whereas holding one in every of my planes of their different hand.

I can really feel the bile rising on the market. You is likely to be pondering I
“push” the brand new planes on college students in some way. Nothing may very well be
much less true. I need to consider that the outdated planes are simply as
good. I used to consider the outdated planes have been simply pretty much as good.

— Christopher Schwarz

Get a ton of handplane info from my e-book “Handplane
” on sale in paperback at

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: